The Lincoln Wheat Penny Valued at $100k, Still in Circulation

Imagine rummaging through a jar of spare change in Denver or New York and discovering a humble penny that could be worth more than a luxury car.

The Lincoln wheat penny—seemingly ordinary and overlooked—has seen a few rare examples fetch astronomical sums at auction, and some are still believed to circulate quietly in pockets and coin rolls today.

One version of this coin is often whispered about in collector circles as a “$100,000 penny,” stirring curiosity and dreams of fortune.

Origins of the Wheat Penny

The Lincoln wheat penny was first produced in 1909 to commemorate the centennial of Abraham Lincoln’s birth. Struck in Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco, these coins featured Lincoln’s portrait on the obverse and two stalks of wheat framing the reverse.

Its production continued until 1958, when the reverse was redesigned. Over the decades, the composition of the coin changed, especially during times of copper shortage, which paved the way for rare misprints and off-metal strikes.

The Famous 1943 Bronze Error

In 1943, the United States Mint intended to make Lincoln cents from zinc-coated steel to free up copper for wartime demands. Yet, by mistake, a small number of pennies were struck using leftover bronze planchets from 1942.

These rare bronze 1943 pennies stand out because most 1943 cents are steel and magnetic, whereas the bronze ones are nonmagnetic. One such coin sold at auction for more than three hundred thousand dollars, fueling legends that one might still turn up in everyday change.

Cities like Philadelphia, Denver, or San Francisco—where these coins may have been originally minted—are often cited by collectors as possible points of discovery, but in truth the coins could have migrated across the country through commerce over the decades.

Other Valuable Wheat Penny Varieties

The “$100,000 penny” phrase is sometimes applied loosely to a few other varieties beyond the 1943 bronze. Among them:

• The 1909-S VDB: Struck in San Francisco, this version bears the initials of the designer, Victor David Brenner. Only a limited number were minted before the initials were removed, making this a prized variety among collectors.
• The 1955 Double Die: In Philadelphia, a misalignment on one die caused the date and lettering to appear doubled. Thousands of these entered circulation, but those in excellent condition are valued greatly today.

Collectors in cities such as Chicago, Los Angeles, or Houston often check rolls from banks in hopes of finding these elusive coins, though actual discoveries are exceedingly rare.

Why So Many Are Still in Circulation

The idea that one of these massive-value pennies is still circulating hinges on a few realities. First, many rare coins were never separated out by everyday holders—they remained mixed in with ordinary change. Second, over the span of seventy or more years, coins have migrated across states, changing hands countless times.

A 1909-S VDB struck in San Francisco might find itself in a laundromat in Seattle or a diner in Boston decades later.

That said, the odds of someone finding one in a random pocket change today are extremely slim. Most high-value examples are already in institutional collections or owned by dedicated numismatists. But the possibility—however remote—adds to the romance and mystery.

What to Look For in Your Pocket Change

If you ever want to chase this dream, here’s a quick checklist:

• Magnet test: Most 1943 pennies are steel and will stick to a magnet. A nonmagnetic 1943 penny is suspicious and might merit further inspection.
• Mint markings: Letters like “S” for San Francisco or “D” for Denver can signal rarer mint runs.
• Wear and detail: Look for sharp edges in the date, inscriptions, and the wheat stalk details.
• Unusual coloring or misalignment: Off-metal strikes or doubling errors are often seen as “short shots” for value.

If you do find a potentially rare example, the best next step is to have it professionally graded by a reputable coin-certifying organization before placing it in a collection or selling it.

The legend of a Lincoln wheat penny worth $100,000 still circulating in some unsuspecting pocket may lean more toward myth than reality, but it’s grounded in real stories of misstrikes, rare varieties, and sky-high auction sales. From San Francisco to Chicago, Denver to Philadelphia, these coins have traveled far and wide.

Though finding one today may be as unlikely as striking gold, the dream lives on in every handful of spare change. If you ever pause to examine a penny and it feels “off,” you might just be holding history in your hand.

FAQs